Advertisements

Debt Rip-Offs: CashNetUSA

Highway Robbery

It sounds like a great idea: Get the cash that you need for a life emergency quickly and privately from the comfort of your own home. With CashNetUSA, you don’t even have to drive to a skeezy part of town to get a payday loan.

I was unaware of CashNetUSA until I spent a random weekday at home recently and flipped on the tube for some quality daytime TV. That’s when I saw an ad for CashNet. This company’s campaign sounds a lot like the advertising you hear for other payday lenders: They offer short-term loans to people who need cash quickly but won’t have more money until their next payday. CashNet operates online, however, and they emphasize safety and trust as part of their sales pitch.

If you’ve read much on this site, you probably know that we’re no fans of debt — we believe that debt is a form of money slavery that can bind up your financial life for years. And payday loans are among the very worst kind of debt, intentionally trapping poor and financially ignorant people in cycles of debt that they may never be able to escape. CashNetUSA functions much like a payday lender in the virtual world. And while some state regulations prohibit CashNet from rolling over payday loans into despicable  cycles of debt, all of the products that this company offers are still a giant rip-off.

The way that CashNet works varies from state to state. In some places, like my home state of Kentucky, current laws don’t allow the company to lend at all. But the company does operate in most states under various forms: Depending on the state you live in, CashNet offers short-term payday loans, lines of credit, medium-term payday loans or loan brokering services with third-party lenders. The details of how you do business with CashNet aren’t all that important, though. The main thing that you need to know is that dealing with these people is very, very expensive.

The trick with short-term lending is that the short term of the loan and the “low” fees associated with borrowing mask the true interest rate involved in these loans. When we talk about the expense of borrowing, the most common way to do it is in terms of the annual percentage rate, or APR — the interest that you pay on the loan. A mortgage loan can be as low as 3% APR right now. Many auto loans are around 5% APR, and credit card interest rates can vary anywhere between 12% and 29% APR. Because you often pay these loans off over several years, it’s natural to look at the cost in terms of the annual percentage rates. But because short-term loans are paid off in weeks or months, the idea of an annual percentage rate doesn’t come up as easily. The problem with that is that without seeing the APR, you don’t have a good point of comparison to judge these loans against others on the market. When you do see the APR on short-term loans, you’ll be astounded.

In Tennessee, for instance, CashNet will loan you $100 for a fee of “just” $15, and you have anywhere between a week and a month to pay the loan back. On the surface, that doesn’t seem like much money — the $15 fee probably isn’t going to break anybody. But remember, that’s 15% of what you borrowed, and you pay it back in less than a month. If you had a credit card with an APR of 15%, you would pay that $15 over the course of an entire year. But because you have to pay all of that money to CashNet on a much shorter term, it means that the true APR of that loan is much, much higher than 15%. We can do some math to determine what that $15 fee translates to in terms of APR (this is called “imputing” the interest rate), and the results are jaw-dropping: Using CashNet in Tennessee results in paying an imputed APR of anywhere between 176% and 684%.

Yes, you read that right. If you borrow $100 and pay it back, along with the $15 fee, a week later, you’ve just borrowed money from CashNetUSA at an interest rate of 684% APR. That number is staggeringly high. Astonishingly high. Infuriatingly high. It’s 15 times higher than most credit card rates, or the rates that local  banks offer on personal loans. It’s a total rip-off.

The details of CashNetUSA transactions vary from state to state, but wherever you live, the imputed interest rates associated with borrowing from this company are absurd. In Missouri, you’ll pay up to 297% APR. Virginia’s rates on CashNet lines of credit are around 299%. In California, the lowest APR available is 207%; the highest available is 805%.

In Louisiana, borrowing from CashNet can leave you paying an APR has high as 912%. That’s abusive, exploitative and wrong in every way. But it gets even worse: CashNet customers in Idaho, Nevada, South Dakota and Rhode Island pay more than anyone in the country — up to a shocking 1140% APR. That’s mind-bendingly high.

No  matter how desperate you are, there is no situation in which it makes financial sense to borrow from CashNetUSA. These guys are peddling debt at the most expensive rates imaginable, and ripping their customers off at every turn. Their 1140% APR is usury, and ought to be illegal in every state. Shame on Idaho, Nevada, South Dakota and Rhode Island for allowing this to happen. And shame on you if you play along.

——

Photo by Geoffrey Fairchild. Used under Creative Commons License.

Advertisements

Comments

  1. I needed to move into an apartment at the last minute and didn’t have money saved up for the deposit. Had no other options that would have put that money in my pocket in time. CashNetUSA charged me $75 for a $400 2 week loan…. totally worth not being homeless. I checked some other payday loan stores, like Ace Cash Express, and they wanted $150 for the $400 loan. That’s a little ridiculous there.

    • Bob, $150 is ridiculous on a $400 loan, you’re right. But $75 is ridiculous, too — when you do the math, that translates into an imputed annual interest rate of 487%. And if you actually paid the loan back in two years, you’re one of the few that do. Most customers end up rolling those loans over end incurring much bigger debts.

      The truth is that no independent adult should find themselves in a situation where they can’t come up with $400 in an emergency, especially if that emergency is homelessness. Payday lenders are no substitute for savings and good financial planning.

      • Hi ,

        I saw where you said that no independent adult should never have a hard time coming up with $400;That statement is true but in the real world he could have had a part time job or anything . You would he suprised if you knew people’s situations.

  2. I did not research this at all before getting $600 for a laptop I needed for school. I’m so screwed it’s not even funny. I set it for 6 months, figuring that’s long enough for my rates to be affordable every month but short enough where I wouldn’t rack up a ton of interest. I was so so wrong.

    I’ve made two payments that are up to $404.07. and I still owe $621, more than my original loan! The monthly payments were higher than they said they’d be and I dont really remember, but I think the program estimated a total of like, $700 being paid back, because of interest. I’m seriously freaking out right now and have no idea what to do. This was the worst decision I’ve ever made.

  3. The fact is, these are short term loans. Meant to be used, and then paid back in full at your next paycheck. To not do so, incurs the enormous interest rates.

  4. Martin George says:

    Years ago I knew credit loans of any kind was a bad idea. Don’t have any credit cards or loans except the 4.5 % interest on my home loan. Paid cash for my used car and cash for everything I purchase.

Trackbacks

  1. […] practices to prey on the poor. Not far behind them are other rip-off agents, including several online operations that offer loans at crazy-high interest rates. Major retail chains and their credit […]

  2. […] they can never escape. Then there are many more that stop just sort of despicability: outfits like CashNet USA, MoneyMutual, Fingerhut and others give short-term loans to consumers at incredibly high rates. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Copyright Brian Jewell, 2011-2013

All of the contents of this site and its posts are copyright of Brian and Laura Jewell. Any redistribution or duplication of this material, without the consent of the authors, is strictly prohibited. Instead, please feel free to link to us. Thanks!

Disclosures

All content on this site is given on a general basis and is intended for informational use only. The content does not reflect any professional legal, investing, accounting or tax advice, and should not be used as the sole basis for making financial decisions. Always consult a certified financial professional before investing.
%d bloggers like this: